Death Papers of Martha Guthrie and the Death Date Discrepancy

Ray City History  

Martha Newbern Guthrie was the wife of Samuel F. Guthrie, and the daughter of Dred Newbern and Elizabeth “Betsy” Sirmans.  According to her grave marker, her birthdate was April 10, 1836.  The papers recording her date of death all show that she died on February 23, 1925.  

Martha Newbern Guthrie was a lifelong resident of Berrien County, Georgia and generations of her descendants have made their homes at Ray City, GA.  Her husband, Samuel F. Guthrie, fought in the Civil War in the 54th Georgia Volunteer Infantry.  After his death in 1910 she applied for and eventually received an annual Confederate Widow’s Pension. Her last application paperwork documents her death and burial arrangements.   

The death certificate of Martha Guthrie shows that her attending physician was Dr. J.V. Talley, of Nashville, GA, from Feb 21st to the 23rd. On the afternoon of February 23, she finally succumbed to “paralysis.”   

Death Certificate of Martha Newbern Guthrie

 

The doctor’s bill, the bill from W.H. Tygart for funeral arrangements, and the death certificate itself all confirm her death occurred on February 23, 1925.   

Why then does her grave marker at Guthrie Cemetery, Berrien County, Georgia give her date of death as January 25, 1925?   

Gravemarker of Martha Newbern Guthrie gives her death date as January 25, 1925.

 

For more history of the Guthrie family in Ray City, GA see http://raycity.pbworks.com

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s